Sunday, September 27, 2020

Ecclesiastes 7:15-18 "Be not overly righteous ... be not overly wicked..." ... What do you mean?


As we live our lives under the sun we need to know that our greatest obstacle and frustration in living this life is our inherited human sinfulness. 

Although  God has made us  originally perfect, wise and upright, Solomon says that “they have sought out many schemes” (7:29).

That is  who we are: schemers, people  wise in our own eyes, and always in search of a plan apart from God!  We waver between wisdom and foolishness at the best of times, and the more we detach ourselves from God, the more foolish we become. We struggle to make sense of life, particularly when it comes to sickness and dying. We have a sense of immortality in us  and  death and sickness don’t make sense.

We also have a sense of fairness in us. 

Unfairness is repulsive to us.  

In v. 15  Solomon  expresses  these frustrations when he says, “In my vain life I have seen everything. There is a righteous man who perishes in his righteousness, and there is a wicked man who prolongs his life in his evildoing.” 

Do you see the problem?  How can a righteous man die an early death, while a wicked man enjoys a long life? According to our sense of fairness, a righteous man  is not supposed do die  early. A wicked man is not supposed  to live long, and yet some wicked men  do  live  to a ripe old age. Solomon says, “In my vain life  I have seen everything. I have seen it all!”  Solomon discovered, much to his agitation,  that the length of a person’s life does not depend upon or godliness  or  spirituality.

It is against  the  greater background  of this chapter  (on living between wisdom and foolishness)  and  in particular against  the background  of  v.15  then  that Solomon now  makes  this  very provocative  observation in 7: 16-18:

Be not overly righteous, and do not make yourself too wise. Why should you destroy yourself? Be not overly wicked, neither be a fool. Why should you die before your time? It is good that you should take hold of this, and from that withhold not your hand, for the one who fears God shall come out from both of them.”  

What does Solomon mean by being ‘not overly righteous‘ and by being ‘not too wise’  and  by being not overly wicked’? 

There’s a real danger of misinterpreting these verses. Walter C. Kaiser, a respected OT theologian warns us that "few verses in Ecclesiastes are more susceptible to incorrect interpretations than 7:16-18."[1]  So, what is the danger of misinterpreting this text?  

Is  Solomon discouraging us  from  being  too  holy or too  righteous? Is he telling us  that  its  OK to sin a little here and a little  there -  to be  a little naughty here and there but  not too wicked? If   this be  the case   then we are faced  with a massive   theological problem.

  • Do we really believe that a holy God will leave an open door for us  to indulge in    ‘respectful immorality’ (don’t be overly wicked!)?

  • Do we  really think that God will indulge us   in a  ‘lukewarm morality’ (don’t be overly righteous)?

  • Do we really believe that  there is  a safe middle ground, as we attempt to live  between an extreme righteousness and  an extreme wickedness?

  •  And if that is so, can we determine where the boundaries are  that  would define  what is ‘not overly righteous  or wicked’?  

You see, if we now follow such reasoning  we will be  in danger of  writing another book of law, another set of rules, determining  (by our  own standards of flawed righteousness) what is  acceptable/ not acceptable. And  then we shall  find that every fallen human culture under the sun will have a different interpretation  of what is ‘overly wicked’ and what is  ‘overly  righteous’.  
This  is exactly what the Pharisees had developed in terms of a system of 613 laws, consisting of 365 negative and of 248 positive laws.
In Jesus’ day this  became a complex and  a burdensome system, and we know that He criticized it severely! Ultimately,  the law of Scripture was summarized in 10 laws alone,   and ultimately they  could be summarized into  two categories: Loving  God – loving one’s neighbour (cf. Mark 12:28-31). 
The brand of Pharisaical law keeping  produced  some tragic flaws:[2]

 (1) New laws continually needed to be invented for new situations.

(2) Accountability to God was replaced by accountability to men.

(3) A person’s ability to personally discern was reduced.

(4) It created a judgmental spirit.

(5) The Pharisees confused personal preferences with divine law.

(6) It produced inconsistencies.

(7) It created a false standard of righteousness.

(8) It became a burden to the Jews.

(9) It was strictly external.

(10) It was rejected by Christ.

So what   thinking concerning  righteousness is Solomon dealing with here?

Solomon is not dealing here with the doctrine of  God’s imputed righteousness,  so central to the Bible. According  to   this doctrine  (and with the hindsight of the NT), to   be right with God,  and to  have peace with God, and to enjoy  a  true sense of the forgiveness of sin(s)  from God,   and having  the hope  of  eternal life  in  heaven,  we must have  a Redeemer that bears our sin. The NT teaches us that Christ bore the believer’s  sins on the cross (1 Peter 2:24). The believer’s  sins were imputed to Jesus. His righteousness  is transferred to the believer.

No one is justified by their own merits. NO one  can be right with God  simply by balancing their lives between  the categories ‘being not overly righteous’  and ‘being not overly wicked‘.  The truth is that no one achieves that perfect balance! In that sense “no-one  is righteous, no , not one… no one is good not even one” (Ps. 14:1-3  cf. Rom. 3:10-12).

No one  will get to heaven  by saying to God, “Well I wasn’t perfect, but then again … I wasn’t terribly sinful!”.  This is  a very common  and  self -righteous assumption  by many!

The  truth is that  God is so holy that all sin (even the tiniest)  is reprehensible and damnable. For every sin you deserve  eternal hell,  for  all sin flies in the face of a holy God. His perfect holiness means  His perfect hatred of sin, and according to that scale of perfect justice, none of us  are sinless and all  deserve to be cut off from God.  

This is where the good news comes in. God, in Christ offers us salvation through His appointed  Redeemer. He does two things for you: He atones (takes away) your sin, and He takes away God’s righteous anger towards  sinners[3]. Only Jesus could do that! (Jude 24,25).

So what is Solomon referring to? This righteousness, and this wickedness  which Solomon refers to here is not a question of  being right with God.  This refers  to something  within  our  life of faith. It is  a  question  of our attitude  within our life of faith in God.

With this  in mind, let us revise  what we have  considered so far:  

Generally speaking we may say  that righteous living and  obedience to the Word of God, prolongs a person’s life, while disobedience and wicked living generally  shorten an individual’s life.

However, this does not mean that the righteous will always live longer than the average person’s lifespan, or that the wicked will live a shorter time than the average.  This is what v. 15  observes.   Ultimately, only God knows what the lifespan is for each individual (Job 14:5; Eccl 3:1–2).

Now the way is clear to explore a very common problem in the life of any believer:  self- righteousness and presumptuousness! Unfortunately  there is  a tendency among believers  to become  “overly righteous”  and “overly wise”, while on the other hand we also find some believers who  will  always  seek to live  on the borders  of  “wickedness”  and  “foolishness”.  One is never quite sure where they stand. To such Solomon has good advice:  

(i)                 The “overly righteous” need to learn  to think of themselves with sober judgement; not “more highly than they ought“ (Rom.12:3). Overly righteous believers generally lack spiritual humility. They are easily tempted to think of themselves as God’s appointed spokesmen  and custodians of His  truth on earth. Wisdom dies with them (Job 12:2). Think here of Job’s comforters. Many Christians think that they are the prime defenders of God and His Word. 

In a 1886 sermon by C.H. Spurgeon’s  entitled, “Christ and His Co-Workers” he says,

“Suppose a number of persons were to take it into their heads that they had to defend a lion, full-grown king of beasts! There he is in the cage, and here come all the soldiers of the army to fight for him. Well, I should suggest to them, if they would not object, and feel that it was humbling to them, that they should kindly stand back, and open the door, and let the lion out! I believe that would be the best way of defending him, for he would take care of himself; and the best 'apology' for the gospel is to let the gospel out.”  

Spurgeon reminds us here  that  we do not need  to defend the Word of God any more than we need to defend  a lion.  

Peter thought that he needed to defend Jesus   when arrested.  He  drew his sword  (Matt 26:51). Jesus rebukes him for this. He did not understand  that this was the plan of God being executed. Peter was  frequently overzealous and overbearing. In his younger days he was not always a careful listener and interpreter of Christ’s words. The ‘overly righteous’  try to tackle every social and moral and political issue, and  have a nearly infallible  opinion on  everything. They are like James and John, the sons of Thunder[4]. They want to call down fire from heaven to destroy God’s enemies (Lk. 9:54). It is significant that Jesus also rebukes them for this!  Some  overly  righteous Christians   try  to answer  every enemy of the gospel. They want to die on every hill, and  some zealous Christians do  die, and they  are  burnt out  or killed   before they reach their  allotted  life span of  70 or 80. 

(ii)               The “overly wicked” and “foolish” Christian on the other hand  lives close  to the  world,   and so  they easily  destroy themselves. They do not flee temptation (1 Tim. 6:11), like Joseph did when tempted by Potiphar’s wife (Gen. 39:12). Examples :

  •        David did not guard his heart, when looking  from the  balcony of his apartment  at a careless, naked woman  bathing  on the top of her roof. He has not made a covenant with his eyes (Job 31:1), and before long he has committed adultery with her. His family history is a tragedy of many  young deaths

  •  Noah is tempted when he loves alcohol too much, and in the state of drunkenness (which is a sin) he  curses one of his sons (Gen.  9:21).

  •  Lot  (who had lived in  the wicked cities  of Sodom and Gomorrah prior to God’s judgement) also became drunk, and  in this state conceived illegitimate  children  by his daughters, thus  producing the  nations  of the Moabites and the Ammonites  (Gen. 19:37,38) who would   later become   bitter enemies  of  Israel, and in their wars  leaving in its wake many deaths

Conclusion   


Verse 18: "It is good that you should take hold of this, and from that withhold not your hand, for the one who fearsGod shall come out from both of them." 

In humility we should take hold of  the true righteousness  that is ours  in Christ, and  from there  seek Him and His strength alone and humbly  learn  from Him. The fear of the Lord is central to all this. “The fear of the Lord is the beginning of wisdom” (Prov. 9:10). Jesus Christ is to the believer “our wisdom and righteousness” (1 Cor. 1:30). We need to learn to lean hard on Him. Solomon warns  us against  “self-righteousness and the pride that comes  with that when we think we have arrivedand know it all.  

Solomon makes  this  also  clear in v. 20: “Surely there is not a righteous man  on earth  who does  good and who never sins.”

In Eccl. 7:15-18, Solomon  discusses the value  and balance of righteousness and wisdom. He has concluded that,

  •     Our fallen human wisdom cannot really explain all of life nor the future (6:10-7:14)

  •       the principle that righteousness brings prosperity is subject to exceptions. Thus, he notes in 7:15 that some righteous people die in spite of their righteousness, and some wicked people live long lives in spite of their wickedness.

  •      In the light of that Solomon offers some helpful counsel. Don’t think that you know everything! Don’t strive for exaggerated righteousness. Don’t try to make yourself the wisest person on earth, for these are not really worthwhile goals. In the end such secondary ambitions  will ruin your life. Likewise, do not become immoral; don’t flirt with sin and  do not  be foolish  as  a Christian,  and think that you will get away  that!  God holds you accountable, and you may put yourself in danger of dying prematurely.

  •       What then of righteousness and wisdom?  Solomon  answers that they are both of great benefit. Grasp them both. If you learn to fear God (which is the important thing to seek after), leaning  hard on  the imputed righteousness of  Jesus for help and wisdom you will come out right in both areas.



[1] Walter C. Kaiser, Jr., Ecclesiastes: Total Life (Chicago, 1979), p. 85.

[3] The twofold  work of Christ on the cross : expiation  ( takes away our sin)  and propitiation  ( deals with the just wrath of God)

[4] Mk 3:17 – Jesus gave  them this name

No comments:

PSALM 3 : Peace in the Midst of the Storm

  This Psalm which is ascribed to David also carries this important piece of information in the superscript:   “ When he fled from his son A...